The key to motivating donors lies in crafting stories that make them the main character. According to fundraising expert Russell James, evoking empathy and generosity requires helping donors see themselves in your cause.
James explains that our brains are wired to act when we can visualize a situation and feel an emotional connection.
But stories about vague groups of people or complicated issues fail to trigger this reaction. Instead, stories should focus on a single relatable character. Details matter, as they help donors form a clear mental image, but too much complexity kills clarity and emotion.
The most compelling stories, then, are the ones donors can picture themselves in.
This could mean describing a character similar in age, location, values or life experiences. Or show how a donor’s own journey relates to your mission. For major gifts, ask open-ended questions to understand what is meaningful to them and frame your work as helping them achieve a personal victory.
One study found people gave nearly twice as much to help one child as to help five. Another showed donations dropped when a story switched from one girl to eight, but rose again when the eight were presented as siblings—a single, cohesive group.
The key is to make the many feel like one so people can connect.
Images also help, but only if donors can identify with the characters. James cites research where people gave more to help pictured children, but only if the children seemed “like them.” Pics of criminals or lizards—not as relatable—backfired.
In the end, people act when a story feels like their own.
Tell donors how they are the heroes, and give them a role in your victory. Make their values and experiences central to your cause. Only then will they truly feel for those you serve. Blend stories of real people with images and details to forge an emotional bond, and you’ll unlock empathy, trust and lifelong donors. The secret, in short, is making it about them.
View the full recording of this session in our Resource Library.